Cookware Center

Planning For Your Christmas Cookie Exchange Pic

Planning For Your Christmas Cookie Exchange Picture

Planning For Your Christmas Cookie Exchange Pic

Most helpful customer reviews

22 of 26 people found the following review helpful.
IT’S THIS YEAR’S BAKING PAN, BUT IT’S AWFUL.
By LIZA PADUPSKY
I’M A LONG-TIME BAKER. HAD HIGH HOPES FOR THIS PAN, BUT THE COOKIES WERE RAW IN THE CENTER, AND WHEN I ADDED MORE BAKING TIME, THEY JUST GOT “MORE DONE” OUTSIDE, BUT REMAINED GOOEY IN THE CENTER. PLUS IT TAKES FOREVER TO “STUFF” THE DOUGH INTO THE LITTLE CREVICES. AND IF ANY DOUGH IS OUTSIDE THE EDGES, YOU GET THAT RIM ON THE COOKIES. ALSO, YOU IF YOU HAVE ONLY ONE OF THESE PANS AND YOU WANT TO MAKE LOTS OF COOKIES, IT TAKES FOREVER. FAR TOO FUSSY AND INEFFICIENT FOR ME. IT WOULD TAKE FOREVER TO DO WITH CHILDREN.

9 of 11 people found the following review helpful.
Terrible cookie sheet
By Mrs Poobah
I’m an experienced cook and baker and this has got to be one of the worse cookie sheets I’ve ever owned. My cookies also came out undercooked in the center and then browned too dark when I added extra time, just like another reviewer. A disaster. I’ll go back to the old way of cutting cookies out with cutters. It works much better than this pan did. A real disappointment and waste of money.

6 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
Great cookies
By Heather
I have no idea how anyone can give this pan a bad review. The cookie recipe is amazing and the cookies come out light and chewy every time. I have the Christmas and Halloween pan and have never had a problem with either. It’s not hard to press the dough into the pan and as long as you spray with cooking spray, the cookies come right out.

See all 12 customer reviews…